Free standard shipping from CHF 90

Free standard shipping from CHF 90

Olives ripening on the branch, from green to violet

How to recognise a good extra virgin olive oil

“Extra virgin” is printed on almost every bottle on the supermarket shelf – yet the oils inside can taste completely different. Some are fresh, green and lively; others are flat or even slightly rancid. Here are six simple checks we use ourselves, as a family that has been growing olives in Sicily since 1911.

1. Read the label: category, origin and varieties

“Extra virgin” is the highest category of olive oil. In Europe it means the oil was extracted only by mechanical means, has a free acidity of no more than 0.8% and shows no taste defects when assessed by trained tasters. Beyond the category, look for:

  • A precise origin. “Blend of EU oils” tells you very little. A country, a region – ideally a producer and a village – is a good sign.
  • The varieties. Serious producers usually name their olives (for example Biancolilla, Nocellara or Cerasuola in Sicily), just as a winemaker names grape varieties.
  • “Cold extraction” or “first cold pressing”. In the EU these terms may only be used when the paste stays below 27 °C, which helps preserve aromas.

2. Look for the harvest date

Olive oil is a fruit juice: it is at its best in the months after the harvest. A best-before date alone does not tell you when the olives were picked. Producers who are proud of their oil usually state the harvest or campaign (for example “harvest 2025”). The fresher, the better.

3. Check the bottle

Light, heat and air are the three enemies of olive oil. A good oil comes in dark glass or a tin, never in a clear bottle standing under shop lights. The colour of the oil itself says nothing about quality – professional tasters even use blue glasses so that the colour does not influence them.

4. Taste it: fruity, bitter, peppery

This is the real test. Pour a little oil into a small glass, warm it in your hand, cover it for a few seconds, then smell and taste. A good extra virgin olive oil shows three positive qualities:

  • Fruity – aromas of fresh olives, cut grass, artichoke, green tomato or almond.
  • Bitter – a pleasant bitterness on the tongue.
  • Pungent – a peppery tickle in the throat. If it makes you cough slightly, that is a good sign, not a defect.

5. Recognise the defects

Some smells and flavours tell you the oil is old or was made from damaged olives:

  • Rancid – like old nuts, crayons or putty: the oil has oxidised.
  • Fusty – like fermented olives or brine: the olives waited too long before being pressed.
  • Musty or winey – mouldy, vinegary notes.

An oil with any of these defects is not a true extra virgin, whatever the label says.

6. Be realistic about the price

Picking olives by hand, pressing them within hours and bottling a small production has a cost. A litre of genuine extra virgin olive oil sold at a very low price should make you curious – it is often an old or blended oil.

How we do it at olio della rocca

In our groves in Alessandria della Rocca, in the hills of southern Sicily, the olives are picked by hand in October and November and pressed where they are harvested, within hours. We bottle our oil in dark glass and name every variety on the label: The Blend (Biancolilla, Nocellara and Cerasuola – fruity, balanced and slightly peppery) and our organic Biancolilla, a single variety that is softer and rounder.

The best way to train your palate? Taste the two side by side. Our Discovery case contains three bottles of each – and you can read more about how we make our oil.

Read next: How to store olive oil (and keep it fresh for longer)

Shopping Cart